If you want to recreate the looks we wore, you’ll need to start by hitting a MAC counter. Our three-day experiment about what exactly constitutes “office-appropriate makeup” began with a day of no makeup at all. Days 2 and 3 were different stories, and below is a breakdown of the products we wore each of those days. It turns out we all use the same mascara, except Jackie, who we are going to exclude from group hangs now. (Just kidding.) FAVIN Day 2, left MAC bronzer in Bronze ($25) Max Factor False Lash Effect mascara ($15 on Amazon) Jordana eyeliner in Black ($1.29) Day 3, right Day 2’s makeup, plus: MAC blush in Ambering Rose ($21) MAC concealer in NW30 ($18) MAC eye shadow in Cross Cultural and Parlor Smoke ($15 each) JACKIE Day 2, left MAC Liquidlast eyeliner ($19.50) bareMinerals Flawless Definition mascara ($18) Day 3, right Day 2’s makeup, plus: MAC lipstick in Ruby Woo ($16) Clinique Even Better makeup, SPF 15 ($27) Mary Kay liquid concealer in Honey Sephora Microsmooth Sculpting Trio in Sophisticated ($21) SHEHNELA Day 2, left Chanel Correcteur Perfection concealer in 40 ($40) Marc Jacobs Perfection powder in Golden Fawn ($46) Chanel Joues Contraste powder blush in Rose Petal ($45) Max Factor False Lash Effect mascara (the same one Favin uses) Stila Stay All Day waterproof liquid eyeliner in Intense Black ($20) Rimmel Special Eyes precision eyeliner pencil in Magic Black ($10 on Amazon) Mojo Spa Angel lip gloss ($12) Day 3, right Day 2’s makeup (except the Chanel powder blush was “In Love” this time), plus: Smashbox Photo Finish Luminizing foundation primer ($15, travel size) Benefit Watt’s Up soft focus highlighter ($30) Chanel Les Beiges Healthy Glow Sheer Color SPF 15 in 40 ($57.50) MAC lip pencil in REDD ($15) ChapStick in Classic Cherry ($1.99 at CVS) MAHREEN Day 2, left Max Factor False Lash Effect mascara (the same one Favin and Shehnela use) Stila Stay All Day waterproof liquid eyeliner in Intense black (the same one Shehnela uses) Smashbox Bronze Lights bronzer in Suntan Matte ($29 at Sephora) Day 3, right Day 2’s makeup, plus: Urban Decay eye shadow in Smog and Creep ($18 each) Stila Stay All Day liquid lipstick in Amore ($22) theBalm Cosmetics Mary-Lou Manizer highlighter ($24)