New York–Style Pizza | Specialty Slices | Featured on Man v. Food | Vegetarian Alternatives

Sample Menu

• Pizza for carnivores: the West Coast Pesto topped with romano and cream cheese, pesto, and chicken
• Pizza for herbivores: a white pie with roasted garlic and three cheeses
• Side: seasoned breadsticks paired with marinara

When to Go: For dinner and a show, stop by at 3:30 p.m. or 8:30 p.m. on Monday–Thursday, when Big Pie typically schedules its Carnivore Challenge. During this 60-minute feat, one hungry duo attempts to eat an 11-pound, meat-laden pizza in exchange for a $250 cash prize. The challenge is as daunting as it sounds—not even the team from the Travel Channel series Man v. Food could conquer it.

Inside Tip: Make sure you show up with an especially hearty appetite. Even single slices are massive here, since they're cut from one of the pizzeria's 30-inch pies.