Sams Rochelle Park Bagels, Rochelle Park

Coffee and bagel may be one of the most iconic duos of modern times; in fact so iconic that one could easily imagine a romantic comedy titled "When Coffee met Bagel" that takes place at Sam's Bagels of Rochelle Park. Here, a freshly-baked bagel pairs with peanut butter and jelly, but later chooses to go steady with sun-dried tomato cream cheese. There are many side characters in this story: from Greek omelet to a variety of wraps and sandwiches, each with a unique combination of flavors. The only downside is that there's no happy ending to that story: the bagel gets eaten and the coffee disappears in mysterious circumstances.